On a business activity statement, the PAYG instalment box is easy to skip over. It sits between the GST and wages figures. Most people fill it in with whatever the ATO suggests or whatever feels affordable that quarter, then forget about it until the tax return arrives.

The Australian Taxation Office (ATO) is giving business owners a reason to look again, quickly. It’s currently contacting taxpayers who have varied their PAYG instalments to nil for multiple years. And they’re asking about their ATO obligations. 

That group is the ATO’s immediate focus, and they are actively contacting businesses already, but the message applies much more widely. The same rules cover every business owner and sole trader who pays instalments. That includes people who pay the ATO’s calculated amount, people who use the instalment rate and anyone who has changed their figures even once.

The rules themselves are simple. PAYG instalments are regular prepayments of the expected tax on business and investment income. Any variation should bring them closer to the expected tax for the year. Instalments can drift away from what a business actually earns. A variation might no longer fit, someone might apply the rate to profit instead of gross income, or rental and dividend income might get left out. The result is nearly always the same: a bigger bill than expected, at the worst possible time.

In Laverton, Heidelberg and Ringwood, seasonal trade, project work and changing client demand can make income hard to predict. That makes now a good time for any small business to look or ask a tax accountant to check whether its instalments still match what it’s really earning. It’s usually an easy fix, as long as it’s done early.

Why the ATO is taking a closer look now

Most people never think about the reasoning behind PAYG instalments, so it’s worth a quick explanation. Employees have tax taken out of every pay packet. By the time they lodge a return, most of their tax has already been paid. Business owners, sole traders and investors don’t get that automatic withholding. 

PAYG instalments do the same job for them. You pay towards your tax as you earn, instead of facing one large lump sum after the year ends.

That only works when the instalments roughly match the tax that ends up being payable. If someone varies their instalments to nil year after year and then has a real tax bill each time, the system isn’t doing its job. The tax is still owed. It’s just paid late, and sometimes it isn’t paid at all because the money has already been spent.

Repeated nil variations are an obvious pattern for the ATO to pick up. A single nil variation in a tough year is perfectly reasonable. Several years of nil variations alongside returns that show a real tax liability tell a different story. The ATO’s letters are a nudge. They remind people what the rules are before the gap gets any wider.

For everyone else, the takeaway is simpler. The ATO is paying attention to whether instalments reflect reality. If yours don’t, now is the time to fix that, not after a letter turns up.

How PAYG instalments should work for your small business

You usually enter the PAYG instalment system automatically once your tax return shows enough business or investment income and a large enough tax bill. After that, the ATO tells you how much to pay and how often. Most small businesses pay quarterly through their activity statement. Some eligible taxpayers can pay one annual instalment instead.

There are two main ways to pay.

The instalment amount. 

The ATO works out a fixed dollar figure for each quarter. It’s based on your most recent tax return and adjusted for expected economic growth. You simply pay what’s shown. It’s the easy option, but it looks backwards. If your business has grown, shrunk or changed since that last return, the amount may no longer fit.

The instalment rate. 

The ATO gives you a percentage, and you apply it to your instalment income each quarter. Because it moves with what you actually earn, this option suits businesses with uneven income. It does take a little more work each quarter.

Two important things to note

Firstly, instalment income is your gross business and investment income, not your profit. For a business, that generally means sales or turnover excluding GST, before you take off expenses. For investors, it includes things like gross rent, interest and dividends. Apply the rate to net profit instead, and you’ll almost certainly underpay.

Secondly, AI tools can be handy for explaining general tax ideas, but they are very risky. They don’t know your business, your records or your full financial picture. They can also make calculation mistakes, use out-of-date rules or misread how a concession applies to you, and the ATO will still hold you responsible for any errors. Your BAS figures, PAYG instalments and record-keeping should be checked by a registered tax agent who can look at the real numbers.

Varying your instalments is allowed, with conditions

Some business owners think a variation is a red flag or a way of dodging tax. It isn’t. The ATO expects people to vary their instalments when their circumstances change, and the system is built to allow it.

You can vary either the instalment amount or the instalment rate if you think the figure you’ve been given will leave you paying too much or too little for the year. 

Common reasons include:

  • Losing a major client or contract
  • A downturn in trade or a slow season that runs longer than usual
  • Large deductible expenses you didn’t have in previous years
  • Selling an investment property, so rental income stops
  • Winding down a business or retiring

Variations work in both directions, too. If your business is growing quickly, you can vary upwards. That spreads the tax across the year and avoids a shock at tax time.

The key point is that a variation should be your best estimate of the tax you’ll actually owe for the year. It isn’t a cash flow tool for a tight quarter, and it shouldn’t be a figure picked because it feels comfortable. A variation based on a realistic estimate, with your reasons written down, is exactly what the system is designed for. A variation to nil, made without any real expectation that no tax will be payable, is the kind of thing the ATO is now asking about.

What happens when you underestimate?

This is where things can get expensive. If you vary your instalments and the varied amount turns out to be too low, the ATO can apply the general interest charge (GIC).

In broad terms, the ATO compares your varied instalments with a benchmark based on the tax you actually end up owing for the year. If your varied amount or rate falls below 85% of that benchmark, GIC may apply to the shortfall. The 85% threshold gives you a reasonable margin for error, because nobody expects a perfect forecast. It doesn’t protect a variation that was well off the mark.

GIC is calculated daily and compounds, so it adds up faster than many people expect. It’s also no longer tax deductible, which makes it even more costly.

Even if no GIC applies, underpaying all year still causes a problem. The full tax bill arrives when you lodge your return. For a sole trader or small business owner, a large unexpected bill can wipe out working capital and force difficult choices about paying suppliers, staff or yourself. And if your instalments rise for the next year because of the higher return, you can end up paying last year’s balance and this year’s first instalment around the same time.

What this looks like for local small businesses

Every business is different, but a few examples show how these issues can play out in Laverton, Heidelberg and Ringwood. The scenarios below are illustrations only.

Laverton. Laverton’s industrial and logistics precincts are home to many transport operators, manufacturers, warehousing businesses and trades. Picture a small freight operator who varied to nil after losing a key contract a few years ago. Since then, the business has picked up new clients and is busier than ever, but the variation has never been revisited. Each year the tax return shows a real liability, and each year a large bill arrives. 

That pattern is exactly what the ATO is now raising with taxpayers. Moving to the instalment rate, applied to actual gross income each quarter, would bring payments back in line without overcommitting in quieter months.

Heidelberg. Heidelberg has a strong health and allied health sector around the Austin Hospital precinct, as well as many professional services firms and local retailers. 

Picture a physiotherapist who has built up a private practice and also owns an investment property. The ATO’s instalment amount was based on an earlier, smaller year, and the rental income has never been factored into her own estimates. 

As the practice grows and rent increases, the gap widens. A quick review that includes both business and investment income would show her instalments are too low and let her vary upwards before the year ends.

Ringwood. Ringwood’s business community covers retail around Eastland, hospitality, trades and a growing number of consultants working from home or shared offices. 

Picture a retailer whose trade peaks around Christmas and slows through winter. Paying a fixed instalment amount can feel too heavy in quiet quarters and too light in busy ones. The instalment rate suits this kind of business better because payments rise and fall with turnover. If the owner chooses to vary instead, the variation needs to reflect the whole year, including the busy period, not just the slow quarter in which it’s lodged.

In each case, the fix is fairly simple. What matters is spotting the gap before it becomes a debt.

Practical steps to stay on track

You don’t need to be a tax expert to keep your PAYG instalments in good shape. A few habits go a long way.

  1. Compare your instalments with your year-to-date results each quarter. Look at your actual income and expenses so far, estimate the full year, and ask whether your instalments are heading towards the right total.
  2. Include every source of instalment income. Business turnover, rent, interest and dividends all belong in the calculation.
  3. Pick the option that suits how you earn. Steady income often works well with the instalment amount. Income that swings between quarters is usually better served by the instalment rate.
  4. Vary when your circumstances change, in either direction. If things have improved, vary upwards as well as down.
  5. Write down the reasons for any variation. Keep a short note with your estimate, the figures behind it and the date you made it.
  6. Revisit old variations. If you varied in a previous year, check that the figure still makes sense today.
  7. Set money aside. Even with accurate instalments, keeping a separate tax account helps you deal with any balance owing when you lodge.
  8. Get advice before you vary to nil. A nil variation is appropriate when you genuinely expect no tax for the year. If you’re unsure, check with an accountant first.

A quick check now saves a harder conversation later

The ATO’s current letters are going to people who have varied their PAYG instalments to nil for several years. Still, the lesson isn’t only for them. Every business owner and sole trader in the system has the same basic job: keep instalments as close as reasonably possible to the expected tax for the year. That applies whether you pay the amount the ATO works out, use the instalment rate, or have adjusted your figures at some point.

Small gaps tend to grow over time. A variation that made sense two years ago may not suit how the business trades today. Investment income can slip out of the calculation, and a strong quarter can come and go without anyone revisiting the numbers. None of these mistakes is unusual. Each one, though, can leave you with a larger bill at tax time and, if a variation turns out to be too low, a general interest charge on top.

Fixing this rarely takes much. Compare your instalments with your actual year-to-date results, include all business and investment income, and record why you chose any figure you vary. Then put a reminder in the diary to check again each quarter. For businesses in Laverton, Heidelberg and Ringwood dealing with seasonal trade, project-based work or uneven client demand, that regular check matters even more.

If you’re not sure your instalments still match what you’re earning, a short review with an affordable small business and tax accountant can confirm you’re on track before the ATO raises it. Roger Boghani & Associates can help you work out the right figure and keep it there all year.

FAQs

Do I have to pay PAYG instalments if my business made a loss last year?

Not necessarily. The ATO usually brings you into the PAYG instalment system based on your most recently lodged tax return, so a loss year often means lower or no instalments. Watch the timing, though. If your business recovers strongly this year, your instalments may not catch up until your next return is processed, and you could end up with a large bill. If trading has clearly improved, putting money aside or voluntarily paying more can make sense. Your accountant can work out whether your current instalments are realistic given what’s actually happening this year.

Can I vary my PAYG instalments more than once in a year?

Yes. You can vary your instalments as your circumstances change, and doing so is often a sign of good management. If you varied down early in the year because work dried up, and then trade picked up, revising the variation helps keep your estimate accurate and lowers the risk of interest. The ATO’s concern is with variations that don’t reflect reality, not with businesses adjusting responsibly. Each variation should be based on your best estimate of your tax for the whole year. Keep notes on how you reached each estimate in case you’re ever asked to explain it.

Will a letter from the ATO about PAYG instalments lead to an audit?

Based on the ATO’s description, these letters are meant to remind taxpayers of their obligations, not to start an audit. Even so, ignoring one isn’t wise. If the pattern of nil variations carries on despite the reminder, it’s reasonable to expect closer attention, although the ATO hasn’t publicly said what the next steps would be. The best response is to review your variation history, update your estimate and, if needed, get professional advice. Showing you’ve acted on the reminder puts you in a much better position if any follow-up does happen.

What happens if I simply can’t afford my PAYG instalments?

Contact the ATO or your tax agent early rather than letting payments slide. Interest can build up quickly on unpaid amounts, and debts are much harder to manage once they’ve grown. The ATO generally offers payment arrangements for eligible taxpayers, and a registered agent can often help set one up. It’s also worth checking whether your instalments are actually too high. If your income has genuinely dropped, a properly worked out variation may be appropriate. What you want to avoid is varying to nil just to ease cash flow when you still expect to owe tax.

Does PAYG instalment income include my rental property and shares?

Generally, yes. Instalment income covers both business and investment income, so gross rent, dividends and interest are usually included. Many small business owners only think about their trading income and forget about their investments, which can lead to consistent underpayment. If your investment portfolio has grown, or you’ve bought a rental property since your last return, your instalments may not yet reflect that. When estimating your tax for a variation, include every source of assessable income, not just what comes through the business bank account. Your accountant can confirm exactly what counts.

Is it better to use the instalment amount or the instalment rate?

It depends on how steady your income is. The amount option is simple. You pay a fixed figure each period based on your last return, which suits stable businesses. The rate option ties payments to your actual gross income each period, so it suits businesses with seasonal or uneven income, because you pay less in quiet periods and more in busy ones. The trade-off is a bit more work each quarter. Neither option is better in every case. The right one is whichever keeps your payments closest to your real tax position without causing cash flow strain.

How can I avoid a big tax bill at the end of the year?

The most reliable habit is to treat tax as money that was never really yours. Open a separate savings account and move a set percentage of income into it every week or month. Review your PAYG instalments at least each quarter against your year-to-date results, and update any variation if your circumstances change. A mid-year check with your accountant, around January or February, gives you time to adjust before the year ends. Small, regular corrections are far easier to manage than one large bill turning up after 30 June when you’re least prepared for it.